Cup performance combined across every season, while preserving each independent Cup franchise entry. A manager with teams in more than one league keeps a separate entry for each; entries are never merged by person.
The workbook's official cumulative total is shown separately from the live combined total, so a live season never overwrites the recorded figure. The workbook approves no tiebreaker, so tied entries share a rank.
| # | Franchise | League | Manager | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 Preseason | Official through 2025 | Live combined | Cup titles |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Show Me Your TDs | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Lerg | 51.18522 | 9.00880 | 7.89942 | 50.30494 | 52.32342 | — | 170.72180 | 170.72180 | — |
| 2 | JGucci | New Jersey Pro Cup I | JGucci | 9.00822 | 8.96882 | 50.06378 | 8.19884 | 89.50070 | — | 165.74036 | 165.74036 | 1 |
| 3 | VicksDogPound | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Victor Cipolla | 87.33652 | 25.16138 | 25.07184 | 6.79006 | 8.10774 | — | 152.46754 | 152.46754 | 1 |
| 4 | MadMozzarella | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Melissa | 29.27276 | 87.12156 | 8.22422 | 12.40276 | 10.19386 | — | 147.21516 | 147.21516 | 1 |
| 5 | dcsports11 | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Dave C | 28.43312 | 21.17722 | 28.36538 | 52.32488 | 9.12560 | — | 139.42620 | 139.42620 | — |
| 6 | RGuarni | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Rob G | 26.21044 | 6.92408 | 8.03310 | 89.50050 | 8.12152 | — | 138.78964 | 138.78964 | 1 |
| 7 | Kylenj | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Kyle | 26.36638 | 50.10686 | 9.16470 | 26.42418 | 26.27078 | — | 138.33290 | 138.33290 | — |
| 8 | HughJanos | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Will C | 10.07844 | 7.98730 | 25.19488 | 28.46758 | 52.43708 | — | 124.16528 | 124.16528 | — |
| 9 | HughJanos | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Will C | 5.90220 | 10.08120 | 87.29380 | 7.11368 | 9.41980 | — | 119.81068 | 119.81068 | 1 |
| 10 | Geider88 | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Matt G | 26.19708 | 10.19190 | 28.24026 | 28.30834 | 25.31174 | — | 118.24932 | 118.24932 | — |
| 11 | RachelHatesEveryone | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Rachel | 6.98668 | 26.16586 | 27.19892 | 29.53514 | 26.38042 | — | 116.26702 | 116.26702 | — |
| 12 | quijimo | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Phil W | 26.14270 | 27.16584 | 24.11684 | 10.14158 | 10.13892 | — | 97.70588 | 97.70588 | — |
| 13 | quijimo | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Phil W | 25.22778 | 8.08072 | 7.99740 | 25.39214 | 26.40446 | — | 93.10250 | 93.10250 | — |
| 14 | Dude Where's Lamar | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | No manager listed | 25.22060 | 24.05402 | 4.76136 | 27.39160 | 4.93328 | — | 86.36086 | 86.36086 | — |
| 15 | dcsports11 | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Dave C | 3.78450 | 8.99104 | 52.28264 | 7.02572 | 11.22122 | — | 83.30512 | 83.30512 | — |
| 16 | Jgucci | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Jgucci | 10.13068 | 27.19332 | 9.16568 | 8.19552 | 27.28892 | — | 81.97412 | 81.97412 | — |
| 17 | Show Me Your TDs | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Lerg | 9.27080 | 26.27176 | 25.25382 | 10.14370 | 10.36030 | — | 81.30038 | 81.30038 | — |
| 18 | Quisp | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Quincy | 9.13726 | 7.01182 | 27.13962 | 8.07476 | 29.35560 | — | 80.71906 | 80.71906 | — |
| 19 | EatShitDummyHead | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Will C | 9.05742 | 9.03530 | 26.26568 | 29.27190 | 6.96710 | — | 80.59740 | 80.59740 | — |
| 20 | Geider88 | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Matt G | 51.12508 | 9.03092 | 10.08910 | 2.96430 | 4.93328 | — | 78.14268 | 78.14268 | — |
| 21 | NYR1887 | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Ryan E | 24.20900 | 9.16872 | 9.02048 | 9.21374 | 26.17552 | — | 77.78746 | 77.78746 | — |
| 22 | Spr3adsh33t | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Matt L | 5.93384 | 51.19006 | 8.94924 | 6.82574 | 3.68246 | — | 76.58134 | 76.58134 | — |
| 23 | Show Me Your TDs | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Lerg | 5.88490 | 26.14618 | 4.87754 | 27.36652 | 10.24852 | — | 74.52366 | 74.52366 | — |
| 24 | JGucci | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Jgucci | 6.98656 | 8.13424 | 8.96774 | 8.32810 | 27.32412 | — | 59.74076 | 59.74076 | — |
| 25 | NYR1887 | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Ryan E | 9.18774 | 26.11060 | 3.60002 | 10.00762 | 4.78472 | — | 53.69070 | 53.69070 | — |
| 26 | Geider88 | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Matt G | 7.07670 | 5.84864 | 5.94344 | 7.20266 | 26.19090 | — | 52.26234 | 52.26234 | — |
| 27 | zmartis | New Jersey Pro Cup I | Zack + Tyler | 9.08499 | 5.76660 | 9.06299 | 9.28974 | 10.14648 | — | 43.35080 | 43.35080 | — |
| 28 | dcsports11 | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Dave C | 7.02899 | 3.57010 | 5.74630 | 8.21216 | 8.02610 | — | 32.58365 | 32.58365 | — |
| 29 | NYR1887 | New Jersey Pro Cup 2 | Ryan E | 4.87036 | 7.90892 | 4.69480 | 7.13312 | 6.98318 | — | 31.59038 | 31.59038 | — |
| 30 | zmartis | New Jersey Pro Cup 3 | Zack + Tyler | 6.78994 | 2.61402 | 8.97512 | 2.79406 | 7.99598 | — | 29.16912 | 29.16912 | — |